BLDC vs PMSM motors: which one and why
, 1 min read
Most electric two- and three-wheelers use one of these two brushless motors. Here is the practical difference.
The article below is in English. The summary and Listen are in your language.
Almost every modern EV uses a brushless motor, and two types dominate: BLDC and PMSM. They are close cousins with different strengths.
BLDC: simple and rugged
A BLDC (brushless DC) motor is driven in simple steps and is cheap, robust and easy to control. It can run a little rougher at low speed and slightly less efficiently, which is fine for many scooters and e-rickshaws.
PMSM: smooth and efficient
A PMSM (permanent magnet synchronous motor) is driven with smooth sine-wave current, so it runs quieter, smoother and more efficiently, especially at low speed and under field-oriented control. It needs a more capable controller, so it costs more.
Both use permanent magnets on the rotor. The real difference is the drive: BLDC uses trapezoidal (six-step) commutation, PMSM uses sinusoidal FOC. Many 'BLDC' scooters today are actually PMSM driven in BLDC mode.
For value vehicles, BLDC keeps cost down; for refinement and efficiency, PMSM with FOC wins.